local roofers michigan

Roofing Material Comparison Chart 2019 with Prices and Pros & Cons

Now that we are well aware of all the materials that can be used in roofing, let’s take a look at the prices of different materials, their longevity and pros and cons of using each material.


Asphalt shingles $50 to $150 per square 15 to 30 years
  • Wide variety in asphalt shingles in terms of colors.
  • Very cheap
  • Easy installation
  • Low durability
  • Least impressive longevity out of all roofing materials.
  • Asphalt does not provide insulation
Wood shingles and shakes $100 to $165 per square 30 to 50 years
  • Made from naturally occurring materials
  • Beautiful to look at.
  • Good longevity for price.
  • Easy installation.
  • Prone to develop mold in damp areas.
  • Wood shakes and shingles may also split.
  • Although wood shingles and shakes are not that expensive, repairs can cost a lot.
Clay and Concrete Tiles $300 to $600 per square Lasts for more than 5 years
  • Long lasting and durable.
  • Non-combustible
  • Safe choice
  • Clay and concrete tiles prove to be energy efficient
  • Clay and concrete tiles can be quite heavy
  • Due to their extra weight, they may require extra framing.
  • Clay and concrete tiles are expensive to buy and install.
Metal (Aluminum, Copper and steel) starts around $100 per square At least 50 years. Could last longer with good care and maintenance.
  • Looks great
  • Impressive durability and longevity.
  • Great solar reflectance
  • Recyclability
  • Lasts twice as long as wood.
  • Energy efficient
  • Environment friendly
  • Relatively expensive.
  • Only Professional installation.
Fiber cement $500 per square 20 to 30 years
  • Can be recycled
  • Non-leaching so roof leaks are avoided.
  • Expensive
Slate $550 to $1000 per square 50 to 100 years
  • Sustainable roofing
  • Probably the most durable and offers longevity the most out of all roofing materials.
  • Fire resistant
  • Naturally occurring so no risk of toxins
  • Lesser splitting as compared to other roofing products.
  • Lesser environmental impact on slate as compared to other roofing materials.
  • Requires little Maintenace.
  • Very expensive to buy and install
  • Slate is very heavy.
  • Extra framing is required to support slate due to its weight.
  • Sometimes, quality can vary.
Synthetic materials Prices start at about $300 a square Warranty up to 50 years, may last longer with good care and proper maintenance.
  • Sturdy
  • Not so expensive
  • Good longevity for price
  • Not heavy
  • A lot of maintenance is not required as compared to other roofing materials.
  • May absorb water.
  • Quality of product may vary.
  • Made synthetically.


This detailed comparison gives us quite a lot of information about roofing materials. Most roofing issues can be solved by choosing the proper materials keeping in mind the climatic region you live in. That, along with regular maintenance is enough to solve most roof problems.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *